In the previous essay, I wrote as if the Book of Numbers (Pentateuch of the Old Testament, episode four) was the funniest book you could ever read. Of course, I only meant the funny parts of it. There are lots of parts that are dreadfully dry, and parts that are downright disgusting.
Among the dreadfully dry parts are lots of instructions for how to build the tabernacle and various things to go with it. Also, detailed instructions for exactly what to make for each sacrifice, which seemed pretty repetitive to me, varying only in the kind of meat to use for each kind of sin and for each kind of official initiation ceremony. Their diet seemed to be meat and flatbread. Maybe the reason for this was that they lived in a desert, where most of the vegetation was edible only by sheep and goats. It is not a very interesting cookbook. Most of the instructions were written three times: first, when God gave detailed instructions to Moses; second, when Moses gave these instructions to Aaron; third, when the priests carried them out. The wording was practically identical each time.
Some parts were interesting, though. The Israelites sent spies into the land of Canaan to check out potential targets for conquest and the expected rewards in terms of booty. The report that came back to Moses was, they produce some amazing agricultural products, such as bunches of grapes that takes two men to carry. Also, the cows were really big. They might have included cows such as what we today call the Belgian Blue which has a natural mutation that causes myostatin (muscle protein) to be produced in double quantity. But the spies also said that the Canaanite soldiers were monstrously big. We don’t stand a chance, said everyone except a guy named Caleb. There is some psychology involved here. The spies saw what they wanted to see, which was, leave these Canaanites alone.
And then there were the parts that were monstrous: the genocides, and the ordeals. The Israelites were ancient people, and perhaps they were no worse than other ancient people. But it does not appear that they were any better, and, indeed, they claimed that these atrocities were commanded by Jehovah. Millions of people still believe this. But do you believe in a God who orders monstrous atrocities? I don’t.
Most of the genocides of the Old Testament were in the book of Judges, where the Israelites put entire cities to the sword, a story repeated over and over. Apparently, Moses said that God wanted the Israelite soldiers to kill everybody. What part of everybody don’t you understand? But the soldiers spared the Midianite women. Was this due to compassion, or just a desire for more sex partners and more offspring? A plague broke out in Israel, and Moses blamed it on the Midianite women, who then had to be slaughtered. This is apparently what counts as a good Sunday School lesson.
And then there is the ordeal. In ancient times, men in power could kill whoever they wanted, unless they were afraid of reprisal. If you had the king’s protection, you could kill anyone. This was a little bit too Wild-West to satisfy the Israelite leaders. This, at least, was to their credit.
Sometimes, when wives would cheat on their husbands, it was because they were evil or were tempted by money. One could say that these wives were evil and, by Moses’ standards, deserved the death penalty. Notice that the men were not, in this instance, condemned to death. You will recall that Jesus called for sparing the life of the woman caught in flagrante delicto, not the man. The reason this was a serious crime was that adultery spoiled a man’s property, that is, his wife.
The problem is that it was not always possible to catch the adulteresses in the act. Usually, two witnesses were required for conviction; but in this case, none were required (verse13). No surveillance cameras back then. But sometimes the husband became suspicious. In most ancient societies, a husband’s suspicion of his wife was enough to get her executed. But, to Moses, this was not enough. He needed experimental verification. On the sole basis of a husband’s suspicion, the wife had to undergo an ordeal: she had to drink muddy water that contained dust (with blood and meat juices) from the ground before sacrificial altars. The two outcomes envisaged (in chapter 5) were that the woman would not get sick, in which case she was considered innocent; or that she would get sick: her “thigh would fall away” and “her body would swell.” (The word ordeal does not merely mean suffering, but suffering intended to reveal guilt or innocence.)
This is an attempt to get evidence in jurisprudence, but I’m sure you can all see that it is ridiculous. Drinking mud from the ground, filled as it was with germs, would, in unlucky women, cause disease. The ordeal is as unrelated to adultery as dunking women is to witchcraft. This is totally barbaric but comes straight from the Book of Numbers.
Even today, we make a distinction between murder and manslaughter. Generally, manslaughter is not premeditated. But sometimes it is hard to tell. This is part of the reason the Book of Numbers specified Cities of Refuge, where killers could go and, at least for a while, be protected from execution. While some people think this is a progressive idea of monotheism, I will note that it is not unique to ancient Israel. Until the 1700s, the Cherokee Tribe in North America also had cities of refuge, and evildoers who had fled could be welcomed home during the Green Corn ceremony.
I can just see Moses, Aaron, and Joshua singing a trio, to a tune from Something Funny Happened on the Way to the Forum: Something ferocious, something atrocious, something for everyone, comedy tonight!



