Showing posts with label inerrancy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inerrancy. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 5, 2016

Not So Inerrant After All

Fundamentalist Christians believe themselves to be personally inerrant when it comes to interpreting the Bible. The Bible is capable of many different interpretations, but a fundamentalist believes that whatever interpretation s/he chooses is inevitably the correct one. For example, they believe that “day” in Genesis 1 means 24 hours; but this cannot be the meaning of “day” in Genesis 2. So they claim that the word has two different meanings in the two chapters. And they believe that this rule of interpretation cannot be wrong, and you are headed straight for hell if you think they are wrong.

But they have quietly allowed their inerrant interpretations to change. A few decades ago, conservative white Christians were absolutely certain that some people were black because of the Curse of Cain, or maybe it was the Curse of Ham, or something, and that they had literal Biblical justification for hating black people and undertaking acts of violence against them. There are still white Biblical fundamentalists who believe this, but it is a comparatively rare belief today. Somehow, in the last few decades, many fundamentalist Christians have changed their beliefs. This has not happened because of federal government force. Maybe it started that way; they were furious about the government enforcing school busing and integration. But today you will find very few fundamentalist Christians who say “I get along with black people only because the federal government forces me to.” Most white fundamentalists genuinely like people of other races. Now.

Why the change? The Bible has not changed. Nor did God appear in the sky and announce, “Hey, uh, listen up; I just decided, uh, that it’s okay to like black people now.” It is the fundamentalists themselves who have changed their beliefs. If fundamentalists are inerrant in their Bible interpretations, then why have their beliefs changed? It is because they learned some things. They learned from experience that black people are just people, with good and bad individuals just like any other race. This means that somebody was wrong sometime. Either modern fundamentalists are insulting the Bible by liking black people, or else their recent predecessors were insulting the Bible by hating black people. Somewhere along the line, somebody interpreted the Bible incorrectly.


When a modern fundamentalist claims that they and they alone know what the correct interpretation of the Bible is, they should remember that earlier fundamentalists made the same claim about beliefs that are now widely rejected.

Thursday, June 16, 2016

What Fundamentalists Think about Themselves

I wrote the following as an introduction to a book I am working on. I decided to not use it, since it has a very negative tone. But I believe it is true and I will post it here for you to look over briefly if you wish.

The term fundamentalist was first used in the 1920s in a series of books, The Fundamentals, published in the United States, which clearly outlined the beliefs that a Christian was supposed to have, based upon a “literal” reading of the Bible. All around these authors, the world was changing rapidly, and they had to figure out which of their beliefs were fundamental, and which could be surrendered. The authors were reacting against a tide of loose morality that they believed was sweeping the country during what we still call “The Roaring Twenties.” The Roaring Twenties came to an end not so much because fundamentalism triumphed but because the Great Depression brought an end to exuberant and spendthrift living.


But “fundamentalist” has come to mean something very different today. It no longer means someone who simply believes the Bible to be literally true. It has come to represent a person who almost treats a Bible as a talisman that makes them superior to other humans—spiritually superior, as if it makes Satan flee from them in terror, and mentally superior, as it makes their minds capable of understanding all eternal truths. It also serves as a badge of membership in an elite society of God’s very, very special Elect. It no longer represents a person who humbly accepts the Word of God; it has come to represent a person who considers himself or herself to be personally inerrant and commanded to be ready for action in God’s name. They may not literally make these claims about themselves, but if you listen to what they say and look at what they do, this is the conclusion that you will have to reach. I used to be a Christian fundamentalist and I did not literally make these claims about myself. I was hesitant and quiet about asserting myself to be superior to non-Christians, and even to non-fundamentalist Christians, in this way. But I knew plenty of other fundamentalists who were neither hesitant nor quiet. Eventually my level of discomfort was so great that I left fundamentalism. I was quite aware of my own imperfections, and finally decided I could no longer place myself in a superior position of authority over other people.

First, consider the unspoken fundamentalist belief in personal inerrancy. They hold their Bibles in the air, and believe that they know the answer to every question about the history of the universe, the story of mankind, and the meaning of life. They know the single correct answer to every political question. They don’t even have to read that Bible. They would be hard-pressed to tell you very many things that are, in fact, in that bible. Ask one of them what the prophets Joel or Amos or Obadiah said. Most of them have never read the entire Bible, or even very much of it, which is strange since they say that a Christian has to live by all of those words. But just having it in their hands gives them the power to know everything, at least everything that matters.

I used to admire my fellow fundamentalists whose Bibles looked well-worn with study. Then I saw one of them, after church, talking with others. He held his soft-leather-bound Bible in his hands and bent it back and forth in a harmless and meaningless manner. So that’s why it looks well worn! Not because he reads it, but because he bends it back and forth whenever he talks to people after church! My Bible looked unstudied, because I kept it in the blue box in which it had originally been given to me and took it out only to use it. My badge of distinction was, of course, the deep stains from the oil on my fingers on the box. This Bible, by the way, was a gift from the other fundamentalists. They were tired of me using my Revised Standard Version. They insisted, quietly since they could not prove it, that the only version of the Bible that was really valid was the English translation that was made in 1611 under the oversight of a king, King James (who was a closet homosexual and had a lover’s-tunnel built between his room and that of his male partner.)

Second, consider their unspoken belief that God has commanded them to be ready for action. They are legislators, or vote for legislators, who want to enshrine a special status for fundamentalism, even if not by name, in state laws. And not just for fundamentalism, but for a whole bushel full of conservative laws that have no direct and clear connection with fundamentalism. Take, for example, gun rights. Nearly all fundamentalists believe that Americans should have nearly unlimited access to firearms. Where did they get this idea? They cannot show it to you in the Bible. Jesus even told his disciple Peter to put his sword away because “those who live by the sword shall die by the sword.” This was clearly meant by Jesus as disapproval of weapons.

At the moment, most fundamentalists believe that all of their actions should be within the law of the land. But I would like to point out how tenuous this belief is. It is based upon only a few scriptures, each of which can be interpreted differently than what fundamentalists currently believe. Jesus said to render under to Caesar what is Caesar’s, so they pay their taxes. The Apostle Paul told them to be subject to the government authorities, so they obey the law. But they all know that there are limits to this authority. Jesus testified during his trial before Pontius Pilate that “My kingdom is not of this world; if it were, then my servants would take up arms.” Nevertheless, when the Roman government or its local subsidiaries commanded Christians to worship Caesar or local gods, they refused. At some point, a line is crossed.

And it is a moving line. Sometimes the line moves back. Fundamentalists find themselves spending less and less time opposing things that they used to consider utterly fundamental, such as racial segregation in the past and gay rights at the present time. Sometimes, as with racial segregation, they will even admit that they have learned some things and that fundamentalists in the past had been wrong. In other cases, as with gay rights, they still believe the same things they did before but are now unwilling to make such a big deal about it—so long as gay people stay out of their churches and don’t teach school and don’t run for public office.

But the line can, under the right circumstances, move forward. Fundamentalists have immense numbers of firearms which they claim they will never use against any human who simply disagrees with them. They want their assault weapons only to play with them, and their handguns only for self-defense. But they are ready. All that is needed is for the religious leaders whose commands they follow to say, “The time has come for us to use those guns.” You think it can never happen, and I hope it can never happen. But there is nothing to prevent it from happening during a time of social disruption, when the government that they claim to respect in God’s name appears to not be functioning in a manner they consider viable. They are ready, at least many of them are.

Many fundamentalists consider themselves commanded to be ready for action because they believe themselves to be personally inerrant. If and when the time comes, they will not have time to consult a Bible for answers about what to do. Should they support Texas secession from the Union, as hundreds of thousands of them now do, or not? Should they oppose government-mandated or even government-encouraged measures for energy efficiency, or should they continue to insist that God wants us to burn up all the oil and coal we can, right now, as millions of them believe? Should they join a militia, as thousands of them have, or not? And should such a militia take up arms against the government, as claimed by one local elected official in Texas, or not? The Bible, which they haven’t read anyway, has no clear answers spelled out to such questions. They have to use their own judgment which they believe is inerrant, so long as they hold that Bible up over their heads.

Friday, September 18, 2015

Why Genesis is Wrong, Even Figuratively, Part One: Human Nature

Most readers of this blog know that the creationist insistence on a literal reading of Genesis is completely wrong. One reason for this is that they are picky about which parts they take literally and which parts they consider figurative. They say the Genesis days are 24 hours but they do not believe the “firmament” is actually firm, as implied in the original Hebrew of Genesis 1, or that rain falls through the “windows of heaven” as stated in Genesis 6. Same old, same old, I won’t bore you with this.

What I consider more interesting is that Genesis is wrong even as a figurative picture of the universe, life on earth, and humankind.

One example of this involves human nature, human evolution, and the origin of society. Christian evolutionists (they do exist) have struggled to figure out which stage of human evolution was represented by Adam and Eve. They believe God made Adam from the “dust of the ground,” but that this phrase refers to matter, which includes DNA and cells. Perhaps, they speculate, that there was a point in history in which the spirit of God infused itself into an existing animal species, Homo sapiens. For centuries, even conservative Bible believers have speculated about the existence of “Pre-Adamite” humans.

However, there appears to be no abrupt point in human evolution in which an animal species became suddenly spiritual. Christians in science who try to reconcile Genesis and evolution have had a devil of a time.

And, I believe, they need not bother. The picture of human origins in Genesis is all wrong. It depicts a primordially sinless human race, which experienced “The Fall,” after which humans had a sinful nature. There has never been a time when humans or any of our evolutionary ancestors have not been fighting and killing one another. As far back as you look, you find what we would call sin. Recently, it was reported that one of the Homo heidelbergensis bodies in Sima de los Huesos in Spain was a murder victim at least 350,000 years ago.

And, furthermore, the Christian story depicts humans as falling not only from primitive sinlessness but into modern depravity, or “original sin.” That is, that modern human nature is evil, unless the person has the Spirit of God living in him or her. But this cannot be true. Human nature is not entirely evil. Human nature is characterized by (imperfect) goodness and altruism within groups—cooperation, even love. It is also characterized by genocidal evil between groups. Human nature has both.

So, for example, good Jewish soldiers under Joshua could carry out genocide against Canaanites with not a second thought, because the Canaanites were outside their group. Good Christian Massachusetts pilgrims could slaughter Pequot villagers with scarcely a second thought because the Pequots were not in their group. (I say scarcely, because in his own record of the events, William Bradford was actually bothered by the screams of the Native Americans as they burned or were shot; however, in God’s name, he suppressed those inconvenient humanitarian thoughts.) In the Confederacy, until recently revered by the state of South Carolina and still worshiped by hundreds of thousands of Christian racists, Christian men and women could torture slaves because they classified slaves as “other,” in particular as property rather than persons. As Jon Stewart and associates said, it is difficult to kill a person, but easy to kill a heretic.

One reason we know the Bible is wrong about human nature is that those religious humans who supposedly have the Spirit of God living in them are no better than any other humans, on the average. Conservative Christians are no more or less likely than anyone else to commit fornication, adultery, financial crimes, etc. The constant stream of Christian televangelist scandals is no different than revelations of scandals in any other group of people, except that televangelists proclaim themselves to be morally superior. Reverend Ted Haggard’s homosexual partner was not bothered by the relationship itself, but by Haggard’s hypocrisy—that’s why he spoke out. If there is an indwelling Spirit, it has no overall effect on Christians compared to non-Christians. I know good Christians and good non-Christians and so do you.

There actually is some good news in human history. Humans have gradually (on the whole, not in every individual instance) expanded their compass to include more and more humans in their group. Who could forget the Wedgwood medallion of the early 19th century, depicting a slave in chains, with the words, “Am I not a man and a brother?” Including slaves in our human family is the only reason they ever got freed.



Therefore, the real picture of human history has been a gradual widening of humanitarianism rather than a sudden Fall from sinlessness into depravity. Furthermore, much and perhaps most of this expansion has occurred in the last few hundred years, long after the completion of the New Covenant and the founding of the Christian Church. In Christian doctrine, New Testament principles as expounded by Jesus were the ultimate expression of goodness, and there has been no improvement since that time.

Consider, for example, Christopher Columbus, about whom I will write as we get closer to October 12. When Columbus tortured and enslaved Native Americans, he was either evil or not. If we believe that the Bible condemns such actions, then Columbus was evil, and we cannot do such things today because they are evil. But if we believe that Columbus was a hero who brought the light of Christianity to the heathens, then he was not evil, and we should be able to do such things today.  No Christian should say “It was OK for Columbus to do those things but it would be wrong for me to do them,” because that implies that during the two thousand years since the New Covenant began God somehow changed the rules.

An evolutionary view, in contrast, would say that since the time of Columbus we have widened our compass of humanitarianism. We can say the standards of good and evil are different now than in Columbus’ day. We cannot condone Columbus (he should have known that rape and murder were wrong) but we can perhaps understand him better. Unlike us, he was raised to think that anyone who was not a member of his holy Catholic Church should die.

In conclusion: Genesis is wrong about human nature and its origin. Genesis implies, even figuratively, that primitive humans were sinless, and modern humans are depraved unless God saves them. An evolutionary view indicates that human nature has always been both good and evil and that morality has evolved.


This essay also appeared on my evolution blog.

Monday, December 1, 2014

Not So Inerrant After All

Fundamentalist Christians believe themselves to be personally inerrant when it comes to interpreting the Bible. The Bible is capable of many different interpretations, but a fundamentalist believes that whatever interpretation s/he chooses is inevitably the correct one. For example, they believe that “day” in Genesis 1 means 24 hours; but this cannot be the meaning of “day” in Genesis 2. So they claim that the word has two different meanings in the two chapters. And they believe that this rule of interpretation cannot be wrong, and you are headed straight for hell if you think they are wrong.

But they have quietly allowed their inerrant interpretations to change. A few decades ago, conservative white Christians were absolutely certain that some people were black because of the Curse of Cain, or maybe it was the Curse of Ham, or something, and that they had literal Biblical justification for hating black people and undertaking acts of violence against them. There are still white Biblical fundamentalists who believe this, but it is a comparatively rare belief today. Somehow, in the last few decades, many fundamentalist Christians have changed their beliefs. This has not happened because of federal government force. Maybe it started that way; they were furious about the government enforcing school busing and integration. But today you will find very few fundamentalist Christians who say “I get along with black people only because the federal government forces me to.” Most white fundamentalists genuinely like people of other races. Now.

Why the change? The Bible has not changed. Nor did God appear in the sky and announce, “Hey, uh, listen up; I just decided, uh, that it’s okay to like black people now.” It is the fundamentalists themselves who have changed their beliefs. If fundamentalists are inerrant in their Bible interpretations, then why have their beliefs changed? It is because they learned some things. They learned from experience that black people are just people, with good and bad individuals just like any other race. This means that somebody was wrong sometime. Either modern fundamentalists are insulting the Bible by liking black people, or else their recent predecessors were insulting the Bible by hating black people. Somewhere along the line, somebody interpreted the Bible incorrectly.


When a modern fundamentalist claims that they and they alone know what the correct interpretation of the Bible is, they should remember that earlier fundamentalists made the same claim about beliefs that are now widely rejected.