Showing posts with label God. Show all posts
Showing posts with label God. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 15, 2026

Stars in the Daytime: Stories of Disruption, by Stan Rice, story 1. When Pigs Fly

Author Stan Rice has just published another collection of short stories: Stars in the Daytime: Stories of Disruption. Stan Rice is better known as a science writer, and scientific content and themes show up in most of his stories, including those in this collection. But his fiction usually contains a lot of thought-provoking religion.

Here is the author’s summary from Amazon: “You cannot see stars in the daytime, but they, like hidden reality, are always there. In these nine stories, Stan Rice asks, what if God appeared in the sky, with a message for Muslims? Can a theme park haunted castle help a young woman escape from genocide? What if an old greenhouse is the site of shifting timelines? What if a hotel burglar is actually a kindly man? What if a man discovers his girlfriend thinks of him as a teddy bear, then needs him? What happens if a demon from hell changes places with a human being on Earth? In one of the stories, Ruth meets Carmen.”

 


The stories in this collection are: When Pigs Fly (reviewed here); The Haunted Castle; Bleeding Earth; The Book of Ruth; The Old Burrill House; The Lord Will Provide: Two Stories of Faith; The Gentleman; Ursa Minor; and You Little Demon (reviewed in later essays).

The first story, When Pigs Fly, is about an American woman (Wendy) who wandered away from her Muslim heritage (she was Wafa before). Then one day, God appeared in the sky. Only, unlike Rice’s novel Glass Cathedral, it was Al-lah, not the Christian God. God said he was going to kill reprobate former Muslims, but He was going to give Wafa an extra chance, since, He said, He just likes her. His only rule is to stay away from pork and pork products.

Wafa rejoins the mosque in which she grew up, in Oklahoma, and thinks she is obeying Al-lah. She has even dedicated her life to making the world better, by getting a college degree in biology. But in her biotechnology class she discovers that pig genes have been sliced into the DNA of almost all crop plants, and that she and all her fellow Muslims have been eating pork without realizing it. So, God killed all of them.

My science blog readers will be interested in the biotechnology by which pig genes are inserted into vegetables. But the question for my religious readers (this blog) is, would God ever do anything like this? Of course not, although a lot of religious people do not realize it. A relationship with God is different for each person, and is a whole life history, rather than a mindless following of one or a few rules. Christians, and Muslims, need to understand this.

Wednesday, May 27, 2026

Glass Cathedral: A Novel that Faces Deep Religious Questions, with Humor, part two

Two of the main characters in Stan Rice’s Glass Cathedral are Dan and Misty. Dan is the atheist and Misty is the Christian, only of course it is not that simple. They are real people who are working through big questions, not like the stifling two-dimensional characters of Pilgrim’s Progress.


By the time God appears in the sky—or not—outside the California desert town of Susurrus, Dan is already an atheist. So what he sees is an unexplained natural phenomenon. But he does not arrive at his atheism thoughtlessly. His whole view of the natural world began when, as a kid, he saw a horsehair worm several inches long protruding from the anus of a cockroach. Nature, he realized, was an arena of struggle and parasitism. (He thus earned the name of Buttworm Boy.)

He did not have a comfortable atheism. He meets, is fascinated by, and is then attracted to a Mormon girl named Margaret. Dan never alters his strong opinion that Mormonism is the stupidest piece of illogical thinking he had ever encountered. But Margaret is not stupid. And as they slip into a physical relationship closer than either had expected, Dan finds himself wanting to believe as Margaret does. But he cannot. Dan’s background story is truly funny. He and Margaret end their contact as he goes to the University of California at Santa Barbara.

Misty, also at UCSB, begins as a dreamily idealistic Christian who lived for her weekly Bible studies and for her fiancĂ© Dwayne. Dan meets Misty just long enough to fall in love with her. Misty and Dwayne plan a mission trip to Ecuador, to convert Catholics to evangelical Protestantism, something of which the Catholics were not fond. Neither were the communist terrorists, who kidnap Dwayne. Just as they release him back into Misty’s loving arms, the communist terrorists shoot him dead, splattering Misty with fragments of the man who was her life.

It’s not supposed to happen this way, Misty thinks. Long after Dwayne’s death was no longer in the national news, Misty visits her old UCSB Bible study. She has changed; they have not; and she realizes how they all had such easy answers to the big questions. She grabs a Bible from one of them and reads from the book of Job, in which God Himself tells Job, you think you have all the answers, don’t you? Well, you don’t. That was her message to her former compatriots as she stomps out.

Misty encounters Dan and they have, despite their religious differences, a truly meaningful conversation. They end up working at the same newspaper out in the desert, where God appears—or not—in the sky. This event seems to wipe all doubt away from Misty’s heart. Or does it? Does it need to? That’s what the rest of the book is about.

Tuesday, May 26, 2026

Glass Cathedral: A Novel that Faces Deep Religious Questions with Humor, part one.

Usually, books that address such questions as Why does God allow suffering and Why does God hide Himself are preachy and heavy. See, you are already bored with it, right? This is true whether the books are Christian (or Jewish or Muslim), or atheistic, such as the books by Richard Dawkins or Sam Harris. These books all have their place.

But in the recently published novel Glass Cathedral, Stan Rice uses humor to explore these questions. It takes the form of a three-way banter among an evangelical Christian (Emilio), an atheist (Dan), and a Christian who has recently had her faith severely shaken (Misty). They more or less agree that the problems would be solved if God would just appear in the sky and explain Himself.

Or not. Would this make any difference?

This is the author’s summary from Amazon:

The newspaper staff writers of a small desert town assume the strange light in the sky is merely sunlight refracted by ice crystals: atheist Dan Hardy; the spiritually-searching Misty Barbour; and even the confirmed Christian editor Emilio Villanueva. Then the light turns out to be God—maybe. This is enough to make Misty leave her doubts behind and marry Emilio. Dan, who was hoping to win Misty’s affection, is skeptical, especially since God showed up on no photographic images, and everyone in town saw God differently. The government authorities declare the light was a mass hallucination.

Emilio and Misty raise money to build a glass cathedral in the desert, near the place they think God appeared. When thousands of people come for the inaugural celebration, a storm pulls the glasshouse into the sky. Misty gets trampled. At the end, Emilio and Misty, who is now disabled, conclude that God’s work is to help people, not to build a cathedral, and even Dan agrees.

 


The setting is that a bright light appears in the sky in the eastern California desert near the town of Susurrus. Dan assumes it is a natural phenomenon. Misty doesn’t care. Even Emilio does not suspect the light is, in fact, God appearing in the sky. God appears only in Susurrus, appears differently to each observer, and refuses to answer questions. But Emilio considers it a vindication of his faith, and Misty is convinced and marries Emilio. Dan, and all the civil and military authorities, consider every possible physical explanation. Meanwhile, Emilio and Misty decide to start a ministry to tell the world that God appeared in the sky in the desert.

As part one of the novel (The Susurrus Event) ends, Emilio and Misty have to confront the fact that their message is not, in fact, a fundamentalist Christian one. There is a part of the gospels in which Jesus says, if your hand causes you to sin, cut it off. If your eye causes you to sin, pluck it out. You can find this in Matthew 5: 29-30. Emilio and Misty flee from a fundamentalist church that does precisely this: plucking out their eyes and chopping off their hands.

There is hardly a page without humor. For example, a heavenly chord fills the sky when God appears. But it is not what humans would consider a beautiful chord. As a matter of fact, it sounds “as if a cosmic butt had seated itself upon the celestial organ keyboard and unstopped every note.”

These discussions and events do not take place on blank slates. Both Dan and Misty have life experiences that strongly determine their reactions to these events, and to one another. That is what my next essay will be about.

Friday, August 9, 2024

As Always, Mark Twain

 

In the previous essay, I tried my hand at humorous creativity to shoot down the idea that a benevolent God is in control of the world. But who was I to think I could do a better job than Samuel Langhorne Clemens, known as Mark Twain?

Mark Twain | Biography & Facts | Britannica

I looked through a collection of Twain’s unpublished writings. He left as many unpublished scribbled sheets as he did published books, if not more. This demonstrates that the success rate of a genius (assuming that is what he was) is probably below fifty percent. In many cases, I can see that these works were unpublishable. They just did not have the compelling wit of his more famous works. Especially in his declining years, he simply did not work as hard as he could have. Genius is not enough; discipline is necessary.

A recurring theme in his unpublished writings is that, if there is a God, He must be cruel. In his essay Thoughts of God, Twain tried to analyze the twisted thought processes of a God who could create the fly. God’s commission to the fly: “Persecute the sick child; settle upon its eyes, its face, its hands, and gnaw and pester and sting…Settle upon the soldier’s festering wounds in field and hospital and drive him frantic while he also prays…” And the plague victim: “sting, feed upon his ulcers, dabble your feet in his rotten blood, gums them thick with plague germs…” At least with humans there is the hope, or delusion, of life after death, but animals suffer from flies, “…all the kindly animals that labor without fair reward here and perish without hope of it hereafter…”

Twain then attacks the idea that, when humans help one another, they are doing God’s work. Twain could not have known John F. Kennedy would say, “Here on Earth, God’s work must tryly be our own.” Twain just considers human good deeds to be God taking credit for someone else’s good work. The only italicized passage says, “There was never yet a case of suffering or sorrow which God could not relieve.” If it is a sin to withhold help when we can give it, God must be a cosmic sinner.

In another essay, In My Bitterness (written when Twain was still bitter about the death in 1896 of his daughter Olivia (Susy) of meningitis), he wrote, “He gives you a healthy body and you are tricked into thanking Him for it; some day, when He has rotted it with disease and made it a hell of pains, you will know why He did it…He may tear the palpitating heart out of your breast and slap you in the face with it.”

In a story at the end of The Refuge of the Derelicts, Twain writes about the cruelty of the spider sucking the life out of her victims, and even her husband, and then along comes a wasp and lays an egg on the spider. The wasp grub “gnawed a hole in the spider’s abdomen, and began to suck her juices while she moaned and wept…” The wasp grub eats the spider from the inside, leaving it alive until the last miserable moment. The wasp was “radiant with that spiritual joy which is the result of duty done.”

Theodicy is the intellectual discipline of making excuses for God. You would think that it would by now have gone extinct. But humans want to believe, despite all evidence, that God is good. That is certainly what I want to believe, but, as Twain would have said, wanting don’t make it so.

Saturday, August 3, 2024

Philosophical Debate of Two Fetuses

I recently became aware, years later than everyone else, about a story that religious people use to “prove” that there can be life after death. It is about two twin fetuses in a womb. One of them is an agnostic, the other a believer, in Life After Birth. The same reasoning used by the two fetuses could be used by us in our discussions of Life After Death. It is a really clever story.

The skeptical fetus says, “What evidence is there for life after birth? We have not seen the outside world, even if there is one, nor has anyone come back into the womb to tell us about it.” The other fetus maintains his/her faith in Life After Birth. The believer insisted that there was such a thing as a “mother.

The conclusion of this story is that just because we cannot see into the afterlife, and just because nobody has come back from it doesn’t prove that there is no such thing as Life After Death. I have no problem admitting that there might be. If the unitary universe theory is true, then it is more than a possibility, but a certainty, even though by this theory we are trapped in our infinitesimal slice of time.

As far as this argument goes, there is nothing wrong with it. But most religious people do not want the rest of us to merely assent to the possibility of life after death. They make claims about the specific content of life after death, and that you ought to believe this content. Things about Heaven and Hell, saints flying amidst clouds, the gates of Heaven, etc. These specific beliefs are unprovable at best and in many cases ridiculous, as Mark Twain showed in Captain Stormfield’s Visit to Heaven.

But fundamentalists take it much further. To illustrate the point, let us continue the story of the two fetuses.

Both fetuses are born, and discover that there is, in fact, Life After Birth. And the Mother somehow knows which fetus was the believer, and which was the skeptic. She holds up the believer, swaddles it in rich clothing, kisses it, and declares that it is the heir of all of her considerable fortune.

Then she turns to the other fetus. “So, little one, you doubted my existence? Here’s what I’m going to do to you. I am going to skewer you and roast you forever over a fire. Your body juices will drip down into the flame, but you will never run out of body juices, because I will continually renew them. You cannot faint, for I will keep you awake. Forever. As punishment for not believing in Life After Birth.

“And if you had believed in Life After Birth, but believed something incorrect about it, it wouldn’t have done you any good. I would still roast you forever in conscious agony.”

“But, how could I have known?” asked the agnostic fetus.

“Your sibling told you,” answered the Mother.

“But how should my sibling have any more credibility than I?”

“Invalid question. Now, let’s get started. Angels, bring me a skewer!”

“But why are you doing this?”

“Because I FREAKING LOVE YOU, that’s why. Now, this is going to hurt as much as possible…”

I could go on, but you get the point. Fundamentalists sometimes use arguments that seem clever, until you start asking questions about them.

Friday, July 30, 2021

Transition from Fundamentalism to Agnosticism, part nine.

 

I wondered why I kept writing in my journal every day. Was it just a “demented polygraphia”? Polygraphia is a mental disorder in which a person must continually write everything down. I admit I fit the description of this very well. But as for my journal, back in 2005, I answered, “It is an act of faith that somebody will want to reconstruct this framework of thought…” The world is like a comet, “which swings close to God’s sun then vanishes again into deep space. The fact that I bother to think and write at all is my fundamental…faith.

“I benefit now from all the soul-building work of the past. If I look upon the world and see only dirt, I am dead and unhappy. I must continue open to inspiration. I turn in disgust from most organized religion…But I remember the powerful inspiration I felt in a field of wildflowers 37 years ago [now 54 years ago]. I reaffirmed it this spring and will keep it alive, as if there is a God, which there probably is.” I was referring to the Sonoran Desert spring wildflowers.

 


But I also wrote, on 29 March, “It is clear to me that in this world, God is not in control. He has permitted a world of natural law, with cruel consequences, a world in which His love penetrates and contradicts, in which His love is of infinite value, and in which our purpose is to oppose all that is not love, all selfishness, even indifference. It is an artificial, contrived cosmos in which God makes us see how desirable love and beauty are, because of its stark contrast with crustal movements which grind all human life as if it were not there, with chromosomal breakages, and with forces of evolution, which have produce a species both intelligent and evil. To angels, goodness is ordinary. To us, goodness is sacrificial. And even if there is not life beyond, we have been permitted to taste and glimpse what is truly beautiful.”

The next day I wrote, “I stride into the future not knowing if God will even keep me alive, but ready in case he does (and, each second, each day, people live more often than they die).” I wrote this even as my illness returned. But even then, I wrote, because of my love for the creation, I was happier than Donald Trump. Yes, I wrote that in 2005, because even back then Trump was in the news as the perfect example of total furious selfishness.

At the same time, I was reluctant to leave religion which was, I thought, a human adaptation. “Religion is our warm hut of order, agnostic freedom is the cold swirling storm.”

Wednesday, June 2, 2021

Transition from Fundamentalism to Agnosticism, Part Five

I wrote on 29 January 2005, “If God is, then God is love, and forgives me when I ask forgiveness for my rage against Him and, in fact, He understands it…I see no God dropping nuggets of revelation from Heaven. That’s because He exists in our wisdom, however obscurely, and since His work is what we do, I can no longer ask for miracles…” There is utterly no evidence of God; the most convincing thing about belief in God is that Antonin Dvorak wrote “thanks be to God” at the end of every one of his pieces of music. I said for a while, I believe in God because Dvorak did.

God, I saw, seems to punish every good deed. I wrote on 6 February 2005, “Jesus is the epitome of every trait that God punishes throughout history…I almost feel I am being punished for loving what is calm, green, and constructive rather than raping the planet like a good consumer…It is enough to make you think that God really does want the lords of the demesne to rule and the rest of us to be serfs.”

I continued suffering, worse and worse despite medication. I thought I would stumble along until sweet death dissolved me. It was almost as if demons were fine-tuning my pain. How would I know? But demons, I figured, were not smart enough to do this. “They would leave a fork-prong or a dab of deviled ham lying around where a scientist would find it” if they caused diseases.

Despite this, I wrote on 12 February, I still had a deep ineradicable joy. “The desire for wisdom is basic to all my perception of the world, no matter how rigidly or fluidly, happily or gloomily, adjectively or adverbially, my physical carnal synapses assemble a model of reality out of the photons, pressures, and chemical compositions of the cosmos around me.” This was the 196th anniversary of Charles Darwin’s birth; I imagine he might have thought the same thing were he alive today. In order to maintain my happiness, I had to wear a hard plastron on my breast to protect my heart as I drag myself over the rough earth. “I attained wisdom, and God saw me, and slapped me down into a gray continuum of semi-wakefulness.”

Nevertheless, I continued to write on that same day, “I am ready to be convinced. Sometimes it seems as if the Spirit of love does make some progress. The false spring, the frost killing the fresh verdure of Prague in 1968 was eventually followed by a true Czech spring; however imperfect, it would have inspired some crazy-dancing hemiola and G double sharps from Dvorak. And to me the beauty of science, literature, poetry, and music are inexpressible; confronted by them, as by a burning bush, I cannot remain morose.”

The result, I wrote on the next day, was counter-intuitive: I was laying each moment at God’s altar. “Then, oh this is wondrous strange, I am free to savor each moment, so I stumble along, deeply happy. I have no life, but only a series of moments each of which I make meaningful. If I live another 30 years, it will not be 30 years but 10,950 days at the beginning of each of which I will say, What, I’m still alive? What shall I do today? I no longer if I live, but if I do, I will make another day of progress towards goals which, if completed, will be good.”

I no longer suffer as much, but I still write down the blessings, as well as the setbacks, of each day. I would recommend that you do also. Write it down. You can look back at it and be amazed at how much, or how little, your life has changed.

Tuesday, May 5, 2020

The Battle for Truth: Does It Matter?


No, not really. At least not in America.

In America today, there is only one real question when it comes to science, or society, or politics, and that is: Will you be a devoted follower of Donald Trump, or not? All data, discussions, and debates are entirely secondary. None of it matters if you have devoted yourself to Donald Trump as the Messiah who will save America, and maybe later the world, if he feels like it.

There are a few, but influential, religious groups who see Trump as the personal representative of God and Jesus Christ on Earth today. To question Him (Trump) is as unthinkable as to question God.



Whether Trump Himself actually believes this or not doesn’t matter. But He uses terminology that strongly encourages godlike reverence for Himself. For example:

Trump called Himself “the chosen one” to lead America into a trade war with China
Trump has repeated the endorsements of people who believe Him to be “the second coming of God”
I still teach and write for the benefit of those who might be interested, but until Trump followers stop worshiping Him, it will really not make any difference.

Saturday, September 7, 2019

Just When We Thought We Had Seen Everything: Sharpiegate

We have become accustomed to Donald Trump considering Himself to be personally inerrant on every subject about which he comments, and that His worshipers believe everything He says even after it has been proven wrong. This is the kind of behavior that you would expect to see from God and His worshipers. Does Donald Trump fantasize that He is God? This started with the very first day of His administration, in which He claimed that His inauguration was the biggest one in American history, photographic evidence to the contrary. And it continues at this moment with Sharpiegate.

At first, there appeared to at least be understandable motives for Trump’s lies. He wants us to think that He is the most popular president in American history, despite the fact that Hillary Clinton got more votes. That is, Donald Trump lost the popular vote. He was one of only four American presidents to win the electoral vote but lose the popular vote. The other three were George W. Bush, Rutherford Hayes, and Benjamin Harrison—all Republicans. (John Quincy Adams, who was president before the modern Republican and Democratic parties existed, also lost the electoral vote, but was selected by the House of Representatives. The fact that Trump legitimately won the election was not good enough. He has a psychological need to be at the very top, not just of votes but of inaugural attendees.

But what possible reason could there be for Sharpiegate? As Hurricane Dorian approached the United States in late August, 2019, the National Weather Service used their standard computer programs and the most current data to predict the most likely path of the hurricane. At that time, they believed that Florida would receive a direct hit. To everyone’s surprise, Dorian turned and went north along the Atlantic coast. At no time did the NWS scientists predict that the hurricane would have a significant impact on Alabama.

But Donald Trump insisted that it would. At a press conference, he held up a placard that showed the NWS-predicted path, which did not include Alabama. But this graph had a line drawn on it that included southern Alabama. It had apparently been drawn on the graph with a blue sharpie. The NWS scientists said that this prediction was wrong. But the top administrators of NOAA, the agency that includes NWS, defended the president. (They, unlike the career scientists, are execute appointees.)


[Photo from the New Yorker]

I, for one, cannot imagine how making His own weather prediction could possibly help Trump’s image. My guess is that He probably did it just because He thinks He can command the winds and the waves the way the Bible says that Jesus did.

At no previous point in American history has scientific thinking been in such danger. For the first time, we have a president Who considers Himself to be an authoritative source of scientific data, literally out of thin air. It is no longer just major concepts such as evolution and global warming that are at risk, but the very data themselves. The Great God Donald Trump creates Truth. I always thought Christians believed that only God could do that.

Tuesday, August 28, 2018

The Jesus Algorithm


Evangelical Christians claim to love Jesus. But to them, Jesus is not a person. He is an algorithm.

An algorithm is a formula or computer code that controls something that happens, for example, that determines what the computer does. It has a certain function, and is valued just for that function. The algorithm certainly cannot decide for itself what to do.

To evangelicals, Jesus has just one function. He forgives sins. You are a sinner, they say, and what you need to do is to press control alt J to activate the Jesus algorithm. If you say the right words, all of your sins are totally forgiven, but if you do not, you are damned. Jesus himself has no say in the matter, any more than a computer does. If you are a good person, who obeys the Golden Rule, and truly loves other people, that does not matter. Jesus is not permitted to forgive or save you. And if you use control alt J, Jesus must forgive you even if he sees into your heart and knows that you are going to just go and do the sinful act again. To evangelicals, Jesus has no intelligence or personality. You have leeway for judgment. Jesus does not.

This is why Donald Trump is the darling of evangelicals despite his numerous, large, and ongoing sins. He uses the algorithm, or maybe has an intern do it for him.



It gets worse. Evangelicals (particularly the televangelists) fantasize that they have exclusive access to the keyboard. A Democrat cannot slip in and press control alt J. If you are a Democrat, you are damned, and there is nothing you can do about it. Republicans, on the other hand, have unlimited access to the keyboard. In fact, most of them seem to have special Cheap Grace apps on their phones that repents of their sins every ten microseconds, so that before they even realized they have sinned, they have asked forgiveness, which God is obligated to give. (Cheap Grace is a term invented by theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer, to refer to this kind of thoughtless repentance that does not cost anything in your life. Back in the 1970s, when I was an evangelical, we all respected Bonhoeffer, whom the Nazis executed. I guess evangelicals don’t do that anymore.)



And God? He’s totally out of the picture. He has given all of his authority to Jesus, who is completely under the control of the evangelicals.

I greatly admire, and love, the Jesus who said “Behold the lilies of the field...even Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed as one of these” and “Ask not what your country can do for you...” Oh, wait, that second one was John F. Kennedy. I think I would really enjoy knowing Jesus, if only the evangelicals did not keep him in a box like a veal calf and prevent him from having any personality.

Monday, October 3, 2016

A Brief Insight from George Carlin

The late comedian George Carlin had this to say in his book, Napalm and Silly Putty.


[God] has a special place, full of fire and smoke and burning and torture and anguish, where he will send you to remain and suffer and burn and choke and scream and cry, forever and ever, till the end of time. But he loves you! He loves you, and he needs money! He’s all-powerful, all-perfect, all-knowing, and all-wise, but somehow…he just can’t handle money. Religion takes in billions of dollars, pays no taxes, and somehow always needs a little more.

Thursday, September 1, 2016

Some Religious Insights from Literature: W. H. Hudson

Green Mansions by W. H. Hudson is a classic. It is considered to be one of those works you have to read at some point. And I admit that it gripped me when I read it, and it was beautifully written.

As I writer, I could recognize numerous problems with the structure of the story, which other writers even contemporaneous with W. H. Hudson would have avoided. The main problem was that it had no closure. It reached a climax, and the climax was extremely vivid. Then after the climax, the narrator just fell apart into depression, stumbled about, and the story ended. This went on for 25 very long pages after the climax. Some of it was very good—especially the image of the white moth doing the same thing that the young woman Rima did—but for the most part it was just heavy depression.

The structure of the story was that the original narrator got a Venezuelan, Mr. Abel, to tell the story he had kept secret all his life. Most of the novel is Abel’s first person account. This makes Green Mansions a double-first-person structure. Briefly, Abel recounted the old man’s story, making it a triple-first-person for a brief period. This would be fine except that, at the end, as I said, there was no closure: there was nothing about any conversation or parting between the author and Abel.

Having such a closure would have solved at least two problems. First, the events in the story were so much like a fantasy—the young woman Rima (flitting around in a skirt of spider silk) seemed too ethereal to be a real person, too good, too naĂŻve, too nimble, which made me think that maybe Abel had imagined her. Abel claimed to have brought Rima’s bones with him in a jar (sorry I had to spoil that). He could have shown the jar to the narrator who, looking inside, would have found it empty. Or not. Anyway, Hudson could have done something with that for a really good ending.

Second, during the long depressing end, Abel told the author about how he had concluded that God either did not exist or was evil. I, like many readers of this blog, found this interesting; but it was just a long rant. How much more interesting it would have been if Abel had told the author what he thought, and the author might have probed and questioned him on it. I believe this is what H. G. Wells would have done.

I want to include here some of the vivid passages that the new atheist Abel spoke. I will repeat them here largely without judgment. They are just vivid, that’s all.

Abel imagined speaking with Rima before she perished in the fire (sorry I had to spoil that): “To me was your cry; but your poor, frail fellow-creature was not there to save, or, failing that, to cast himself into the flames with you, hating God.”

Then he continued (in these fragments from the next twenty pages). “Thus, in my insufferable pain, I spoke aloud; alone in that solitary place, a bleeding fugitive in the dark night, looking up at the stars I cursed the Author of my being and called on Him to take back the abhorred gift of life.

“Yet, according to my philosophy, how vain it was! All my bitterness and hatred and defiance were as empty, as ineffectual, as utterly futile, as are the supplications of the meek worshiper, and no more than the whisper of a leaf, the light whir of an insect’s wing…when I thanked Him on my knees for guiding me to where I had heard so sweet and mysterious a melody, or hated and defied Him as now, it all came from Him—love and hate, good and evil…though my cries did not touch nor come near Him they would yet hurt me; and, just as a prisoner maddened at his unjust fate beats against the stone walls of his cell until he falls back bruised and bleeding on the floor, so did I wilfully bruise my own soul, and knew that those wounds I gave myself would not heal.

“For no reaction, or submission, had followed on that furious revolt against the unknown being, personal or not, that is behind nature, in whose existence I believed. I was still in revolt: I would hate Him, and show my hatred by being like Him, as He appears to us reflected in that mirror of Nature. Had he given me good gifts—the sense of right and wrong and sweet humanity? The beautiful sacred flower He had caused to grow in me I would crush ruthlessly; its beauty and fragrance and grace would be dead forever; there was nothing evil, nothing cruel and contrary to my nature, that I would not be guilty of, glorying in my guilt.

“For they were all dead at last, old and young, all who had lighted the fire round that great green tree in which Rima had taken refuge, who had danced round the blaze, shouting, ‘Burn! Burn!’

“That is my philosophy still: prayers, austerities, good works—they avail nothing, and there is no intercession, and outside of the soul there is no forgiveness in heaven or earth for sin.”


Green Mansions is one of those novels that is so gripping and flawed that I fantasize that someday I will write my own version of it. Or not. 

Sunday, October 18, 2015

Whence Goodness?

Ever since Plato (or even before; cavemen and cavewomen could have discussed this also) people have recognized two possible fundamental sources for the standards of what is good and what is evil.

One of these standards is God. God defines what is good. God does whatever he likes, and so goodness is whatever God does and likes. God says love is good, therefore it is. He could just as easily and arbitrarily have said that hatred, genocide, and slavery are good, but he didn’t. This is the doctrinal position of most monotheists today.

The problem with this argument is that the only way we can know what God thinks is good is to have somebody tell us. The heavens themselves are silent. Most monotheists tell us that scripture (Torah, Bible, Koran) tell us what God thinks is good. But we find, in these sources, no consistent statement about what is good. God tells Joshua to commit genocide against the indigenous people of Palestine, even killing all of the children. The Old Testament also approves of slavery. It places limits on slavery, but makes it very clear that, to the slave owner, “the slave is his money.” But the Bible also exalts love as the ultimate good (God is love). So how would we, today, decide what is good in any given circumstance? Well, you have to believe what the self-appointed preachers tell you to believe. They tell you that genocide is bad when the people of whom they do not approve do it (Hitler, Pol Pot, Stalin, etc.) but is good when the people of whom they approve do it (Columbus, etc.). So the standard of what is good and what is evil ultimately rests on what the preachers—many of whom are not well educated, even in Biblical scholarship—tell us.

The second argument is to say that the standards of good and evil are fundamental to the universe, to all possible universes, and that God is good because he is the embodiment and force of these standards. This means, of course, that there is something higher than God, to which God must conform. Therefore, argue atheists, God is not a necessary hypothesis.

We are no closer to a resolution of this problem than were thinkers in the days of Plato. Moreover, maybe these two arguments are the same. If God is not an independent person with whims and emotions, then God and the universal standards may be one and the same thing. Many religious people, though not fundamentalists, accept this solution, which isn’t really a solution but it, at least, gives us something to live by.

Actually, evolutionary science gives us an explanation. Love (as expressed through the emotion of empathy and the behavior of altruism) is the ultimate good in our species, though of course there are countless exceptions. Love is our instinct (except in psychopaths), though often not our behavior. But maybe in the Klingon universe the opposite is true? Evolutionary science indicates that this is impossible. Any sentient species that loves hatred will drive itself into extinction. They would all fight each other until the last one died alone. Simple as that. That’s why there are no animal species on Earth that do not at least have rudimentary altruism. Heck, even bacteria have a little bit of it.


This would mean that God is unnecessary as the ground of goodness. Of course, how can I know? I am trapped inside my theistic brain. When I look at the beautiful world this morning, as my wife and I take a walk, I see God. Illusion? Reality? It’s not like I can, with my animal brain, tell the difference.

Friday, April 3, 2015

Good Friday Message: What Kind of a God Would You Be?

I guess I wouldn’t make a very effective God. The real God, if there is one, makes certain that the laws of nature ruthlessly afflict anyone who happens to have bad luck, for example inheriting certain bad mutations, or happens to get a contagious disease. Would you be able to do this? I couldn’t do this. I would be unable to resist helping those who suffer and who beg for help. I would not be able to be as cruel as religious people think God is. I just couldn’t do it. I would be too much of a bleeding heart. You probably would be too.

That is, I would be more like Jesus and less like God.

I understand the argument that God lets people suffer because God expects other humans to come to the rescue. But this argument has many exceptions. What about the situations where nobody is available to help? What about the situations when there is no way to help? In these cases, only God can help, and he does not.

Oh, and of course, a competent God would have to send to Hell anyone who got their doctrine wrong.


Oh well. You can’t have a bleeding-heart God running the world, I guess.

Saturday, January 31, 2015

Have You Ever Read Moby Dick?

I finally read Moby Dick, the 1851 novel by Herman Melville. It is famous for being famous. It is one of the best examples of the kind of novel that nobody could ever publish today. It gets interesting about page 700. It is filled with hortatory language in which Melville is quite literally and vigorously preaching to the readers, “O ye foolish mortals,” over and over. Melville injects drama into scenes with none, but in the exciting climax of the book—somewhere after page 700—Melville uses the passive voice: “The harpoon was darted.” The characters are memorable but do not seem real, especially when they are reciting long soliloquies, using words such as uninterpenetratingly. Instead of developing characters, Melville usually just describes them; he calls Captain Ahab “monomaniacal” about four dozen times. Whole chapters of textbook-like information are inserted right into the midst of the plot. There is no consistent point of view; he throws in things that Ishmael could not possibly have seen, such as what goes on at the captain’s table. The book is full of errors (such as assuming that gold tarnishes), which the editor of the volume I read had to correct. For example, did the ship have a steering wheel, or a tiller? Melville is inconsistent.

Of course, it has some very bold and striking features, starting with the first line, which everyone knows: “Call me Ishmael.” And Melville pushes the limit of what a novel can be, in ways still considered daring. Some of the chapters are in the form of a dramatic script, Enter Ahab and all that. I wish editors would let writers get away with that today. And much of the language is astonishingly beautiful and creative. Just one example from near the beginning: An ice palace made of frozen sighs. Try writing something better than that.

And it has some unforgettable scenes, such as Ahab catching the ball-lightning on his harpoon, or the sharks around the whale-boats in their final attack, and Moby Dick bristling with harpoons of previous unsuccessful attacks, and the dead “Parsee” who was being dragged around by Moby Dick bobs up from the deep. And then, Queequeg’s coffin, transformed into a life-buoy, springs up from the very center of the vortex in which Moby Dick drew down the ship. And then, in the final irony, Ishmael (the lone survivor) is rescued by the very ship that Ahab refused to help. These fine scenes get lost in Melville’s clutter.

But perhaps the most striking thing, especially at the time it was published, is Melville’s direct assault on cherished religious assumptions, which is why I am writing about it in this blog. The whole novel is imbued with an awareness of a spiritual significance of the world, especially when he considers the “watery part of the world” that most writers and readers knew little about. Everything—not just Ahab vs. Moby Dick—is a symbol of good vs. evil, and strength vs. strength. It is certainly not atheistic or materialistic. But Melville does focus squarely on upsetting nineteenth-century American Christianity. For example, we violently kill whales to get oil for lamps to “illuminate the solemn churches that preach unconditional inoffensiveness by all to all.”

The first and most striking example of this is how Ishmael meets Queequeg, the barbarian from some imaginary Pacific island. When Melville calls him a cannibal, this is apparently just a general epithet. Queequeg is introduced in the most frightening way. Ishmael discovers that he must share a bed with him! And yet he develops an intimate friendship with this “savage.” Queequeg spears steaks with his harpoon, and goes into a trance worshipping his little idol. And yet, what does Melville, through the character of Ishmael, say about him? “Better sleep with a sober cannibal than a drunken Christian,” and, “I’ll try a pagan friend…since Christian kindness has proved but hollow courtesy.” Ishmael has to deal with his own prejudices, then ends up comparing Queequeg to George Washington. Then he has to decide how to respond to Queequeg’s demand that he bow before the idol, something that conventional Christians would say would send his soul to hell. But he rationalizes that to do the will of God is worship, and God’s will is the golden rule, and so out of love for Queequeg he bows before the idol. Alas, very soon, Ishmael seems to care nothing for Queequeg, hardly talks with him, seems to show no emotion when Queequeg almost dies of a fever, and then when he actually does die at the end (spoiler). In fact, all three harpooneers are heroically strong, and all three are of racial origins that Melville’s white American readers might despise: Queequeg; Tashtego the Native American; and Daggoo the African. Even though Melville described Daggoo as a “negro-savage,” he said, a “…white man standing before him seemed a white flag come to beg truce of a fortress.” There is also the little black boy Pip, who was a tragic figure, and the insane Ahab kept imagining Pip with him, and talked to him after he was dead. Melville notes that, in Alabama, a whale’s oil would sell for thirty times the price that Pip would bring.

In fact, Melville’s spirituality is a challenge to American Christianity of his day (and ours). Melville saw God in everyone, not just white Christians. “Thou shalt see it [the presence of God] shining in the arm that wields a pick or drives a spike…His omnipresence, our divine equality!” Even the idea of the dignity of the common man was relatively new in literature. Melville considered humans overall to be “noble and sparkling”. He says, “Heaven have mercy on us all—Presbyterian and pagan alike—for we are all somehow cracked about the head, and sadly need mending.” Therefore, he could only conclude, “…hell is an idea first born on an undigested apple-dumpling…” an idea which cannot be taken seriously if you believe that God is love. True savages, says Melville, are found in the shadows of churches. He contrasts Ishmael’s religion with Stubb’s nihilism; Stubb said, “…think not, is my eleventh commandment, and sleep when you can, is my twelfth…”

Part of Ahab’s tragedy is that he considered his pursuit of Moby Dick to be the ultimate religious reality, starting with a sort of eucharist with the pewter urn, and rum in the goblet ends of the harpoons. The harpooneers and the whole crew are a sworn holy army against the devil, which is the white whale.

But I think a whole tradition has arisen in which scholars have tried to read as much symbolism as possible into this book, even more than Melville himself put in. In the library copy I read, someone wrote marginalia in chapter LXVIII. These notes said that the skin of the whale was God: “Where is He? What is He?” Then the reader noted that the skin was the Word of God.  The heiroglyphical marks inside the blubber was “rejection of Christ’s God, focusing on pagan.” Melville noted that blubber allowed the whale to be comfortable in all seas and at all times, but the marginalia-scribbler added, “all expansive like God, awe—God is good even to whales who cannot understand. The whale had great abilities like God/Jesus.” The warm whale was in the world but not of it, as a Christian should be. And so on. This thick jungle of notes was written only for this one chapter. Some pious reader out-Melvilled Melville, but couldn’t keep it up for the whole CXXXV chapters.


Well, there it is. I distilled the religious significance out of the 724 pages, and it will be archived here for any time you want to refer back to it.