Showing posts with label oppression. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oppression. Show all posts

Monday, March 15, 2021

Joseph L. Lewis was the leader of the Freethinkers in America for most of the first half of the twentieth century. He was as zealous in his fight against religion as any preacher could be in support of it. I recently read a collection of his essays, which the Freethought Press put together into a book using the plates from Lewis’s pamphlets—without even adding page numbers. Much of it got pretty tiresome, especially when it seemed as if Lewis was offended by anyone around him who was religious. He wrote insulting letters to Billy Graham, and his television interviews (including on May 22, 1957, by a very young Mike Wallace) were rambling in their anti-religious assertions. Lewis wrote, “Throughout the ages religion has imprisoned and chained and stultified the brain of man.” He wrote this same idea in various ways—but almost always using the word stultified—throughout his work.

But Lewis had some good points. Religion has often held back scientific, and human, progress. He didn’t just mean evolution, about which he had relatively little to say. One of his examples was that Timothy Dwight, President of Yale College, preached against smallpox vaccination because, he said, smallpox was the decree of God. (I wonder what Lewis would think of the religious opposition to vaccination and mask-wearing today.) He also said that some religious people objected to Benjamin Franklin’s invention of the lightning rod because, they believed, lightning struck whenever and wherever God wanted it to, and intended the consequences.

Many religious people think that people without religious faith are evil. But Lewis was boundless in his celebration of Thomas Paine, who was praised by the Americans during the Revolution but vilified later for his lack of religious faith. Paine devoted himself to making life better for everyone. He even, in 1800, proposed a Congress of Nations (similar to the League of Nations and later the more-or-less successful United Nations) to prevent war. Lewis also praised Robert Ingersoll, who also dedicated himself to improving the lot of humankind. These famous freethinkers did not use their lack of religion as an excuse to take advantage of other people, as many preachers use their religion to do. It seems that most of Lewis’s work was to go around the world and preside over the unveiling of statues of Paine and Ingersoll.

Clearly, Thomas Jefferson was a freethinker. He wrote, “In every country and in every age, the priest has been hostile to liberty.” Jefferson urged us to “question with boldness even the existence of God,” since, if God exists, He would be more pleased with our intelligent belief than with ignorant superstitious devotion. But when Lewis tried to prove that Abraham Lincoln was a freethinker, the result is much less clear.

Lewis brought up some good points about Biblical history being unbelievable. For example, the story of Moses. Moses led the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt, according to the Bible. But there is no record of this in Egypt. Most fundamentalists say this is because the Egyptians didn’t want anyone to know about the embarrassing Exodus of the slaves. But surely, said Lewis, the next dynasty would have written about how the preceding dynasty had messed up and allowed slaves to escape. Then, Moses came down the mountain with tablets of stone on which the very finger of God Himself had carved the commandments. When Moses saw the idolatry of the Israelites, he threw the tablets and shattered them. This seems a really odd thing to do with tablets that God Himself had written. Then Moses went back up the mountain. This time, it was Moses who carved the tablets, God just dictating, according to Lewis. This reminds me of the golden tablets of Joseph Smith, founder of Mormonism. The tablets on display in Salt Lake City are replicates of the originals that somehow mysteriously got lost. Funny how vital evidence supporting the truth of religion gets lost over and over.

Though the repetitive writing got tedious, I learned some things from reading the works of Joseph Lewis.

Friday, July 3, 2020

Fourth of July, Celebrating What? Part two.


As I posted previously, the Fourth of July is a celebration of white supremacy.

The “self-evident truths” about “unalienable rights” applied only to white men, later to white women, and never completely to people with darker skin. Non-white people have very little to celebrate.

I have reached the conclusion, slowly over the years, that the white races have been the primary source of evil in the world. In many places around the world, lighter-skinned people have conquered and enslaved darker-skinned people. This was even true in India, where lighter-skinned people invading from the north conquered darker-skinned southern people and created a caste system to keep the dark people suppressed. The genetic signature—a Y chromosome from lighter races—proves that, in many parts of the world, light-skinned men dominated and inseminated dark women, as described in David Reich’s masterful book Who We Are and How We Got Here: Ancient DNA and the New Science of the Human Past.

We all know that each and every human being is both good and evil at the same time, and that every race, however defined, has both good and bad people. But I have now concluded that the people of the world should make the preliminary assumption that white people are evil. That is, this is what we should assume in the absence of further evidence; the null hypothesis should be that white people are evil. What this means is that white people carry a burden of guilt for being the primary oppressors in human history. It is therefore the responsibility of every white person to present evidence for public examination that they are actively dedicating their lives to making the world a better place. It is not good enough for white people to simply not be bad. White people should have to prove themselves good, or otherwise should be assumed to be evil. The burden of proof is therefore on white people to prove themselves to be good.

For many or most white people, this should be pretty easy to do. Just post on your social media outlets the evidence that you are a good person who loves people of other races. But if you remain silent, the dark majority of the world will assume that you are one of the oppressors.

For dark people, the world should make the preliminary assumption that they are good. This is the null hypothesis, to be accepted in the absence of further evidence. Of course, many of them are not, and the evidence for it comes from criminal records, financial or other scandals, etc.

Therefore, I proclaim to you what we must do. White people must present evidence that they are actively performing acts of goodness, while for dark people, all you have to do is not be evil.

Every person is still responsible for their own goodness or evil. If you are religious, you would say that God judges each of us individually, regardless of race. But the standards of evidence are different. White people have to work to counteract our history of evil; dark people just have to not make it worse.

What about those of us of mixed ancestry? I celebrate my Cherokee ancestry, but I look white. I am ashamed of my white ancestry, but what can I do? I must err on the side of love: I will make myself obviously good, so as to stand out from the history of evil created by my white ancestors. Maybe I don’t have to try as hard as a pure white man, but I still need to work hard. If you are half-white, you might have it easier, but you still have work to do.

When you have a world full of white people and almost-white people trying to make the world better, and dark people just not being evil, that sounds like a much better world than the one we live in right now.



And with all of this, I don’t have time to go around shooting off fireworks and driving a big pickup truck around with a Confederate flag waving from it. Okay, my fellow whites and almost-whites: get busy, and post on social media about the good things you are doing. Maybe you are already doing them. Well, let your neighbors, especially your dark neighbors, know you care about them. This will lead us to the next essay.

This essay has appeared in a blog about evolution primarily because, from an evolutionary viewpoint, human races do not actually exist.

Wednesday, July 25, 2018

The Danger from Christian Fundamentalists, part four.


Elicka Peterson Sparks, in her book The Devil You Know, draws links between conservative Christianity and crime. As a criminologist, she knows what she is talking about. The first link was that violence is part of Who God is, according to a long, long list of Bible passages. A Bible-based society, therefore, is one in which violence is one of the possible options in social interactions. The second is that fundamentalists like to pretend that the Bible demands harsh punishment, usually death, for a long list of perceived offenses, something that results in high incarceration rates and higher crime rates.

The third link is through Biblical oppression of women. Most crimes are committed by men, many of them against women, as with rape and domestic violence. The relatively small number of domestic violence cases of women against men are often, as in the infamous Lorena Bobbitt case, women taking revenge for abuse by men.

All of ancient society, in which the Bible was written, was misogynistic. The question of whether the Bible is more, or less, misogynistic than its social context is irrelevant. Fundamentalists pick out the passages that oppress women and hold them up as the will of God. In the Bible, as in the world at large, a woman has to marry whomever her father orders her to marry. Women are property.

The general attitude, enhanced by fundamentalism, that women are lesser creatures contributes to an atmosphere that contains rape and domestic violence. In the Old Testament, rape is a property offense. If a man rapes a woman, the rapist has to pay the woman’s father, then she is required to marry the rapist. Happy ending! Deuteronomy 21:11 permits conquering Israelite men to take captive women as their wives, plural. They are spoils of war.

My old fundamentalist self, like many modern Christians, tried to deny this. We emphasized the passage in which the Apostle Paul told husbands to love their wives. Clearly, according to conservative Christianity, a man is not supposed to viciously harm his wife; he is supposed to treat her nicely even while treating her as property.

Even though the Bible does not say it, many fundamentalist Christians believe that women want to be molested. President Trump said that women enjoy having their pussies grabbed by rich men. Many Christians believe everything Trump says as if it were in the Bible. Maybe they think it is. Most of them haven’t read the Bible.

In the next essay, I will present some final thoughts that came to me as I ready Sparks’s book.

Tuesday, December 5, 2017

Novel as Experiment in Whitehead’s Underground Railroad

Colson Whitehead’s The Underground Railroad was one of the most famous novels of 2016. In this novel, a young slave Cora escapes from Georgia on the Underground Railroad, and eventually...does she make it? I won’t spoil the ending. But in this novel the Railroad is really a railroad, with railroad cars on tracks running through tunnels.

One impression is inescapable, and intentional. The amount of deliberate suffering inflicted by slave owners and slave hunters on the slaves, and even on other whites, is almost infinitely brutal. In this novel, slave hunters would kill and rape white abolitionists. Slave owners would put the eyes out of a slave who tried to learn to read. A white daughter turned in her parents to be hanged for hiding a fugitive slave (Cora), in return for an elevation of her social status. One slave hunter wore a necklace made out of human ears. One slave owner tortured his male slave by cutting off the slave’s manhood, stuffing it in the slave’s mouth, and sewing it shut.

Remember, this is fiction. Many of these things did not actually happen. For example, it makes no economic sense for slave owners to torture and kill their slaves for minor infractions; slaves were expensive to buy and maintain. Slave owners would, in the real South, treat slaves like animals, but not usually worse. But Whitehead achieves the novelist’s purpose, to make the reader hate slavery, and to see how it turns slave owners into devils.

And then I realized that this was the point. Most of these brutal things occurred at some point in history, but not all at once. During the lynchings after the Civil War, whites would indeed torture blacks. In doing so, they were not losing any money, the way slave owners would have. Whitehead took actual events from the lynching period and stuck them into the time of slavery. Whitehead also created a superficially nice-looking South Carolina, where black escapees were treated nicely, but it turns out that they were being sterilized in the name of scientific eugenics, and being used in scientific experiments. These things actually happened in the first half of the twentieth century. By placing the brutalities of fictional Georgia and North Carolina alongside the superficial niceness of the fictional South Carolina, Whitehead was inviting us to compare them. Were eugenics and scientific experimentation (as in the Tuskegee experiments), any less brutal than slavery? We usually don’t ask that question, because they occurred separately in history. Whitehead lines them all up during one brief time in Cora’s life. He performs an experiment with history. Hypothesis: eugenics is less brutal than slavery. Conclusion: No, they are both brutal.

I tried this kind of literary experiment when I was in junior high. I wrote a short story in which I divided England into two counties, Rupertshire and Spratleyshire, and I gave them two different forms of government. I set them side by side and allowed a traveler to directly compare them. That’s all I remember about this story, which might be in a box somewhere.

The Underground Railroad will certainly stir your fury. The young escaped slave Cora did not take every opportunity for revenge that came to her. I found myself wishing she had tortured and slowly killed the slave catcher in Indiana, rather than leaving him alive and tied up. That is, Whitehead stirred my desire for revenge then confronted me with mercy. This literary theme will never grow old.

Colson Whitehead broke up the timeline of history in a way that is forbidden in most historical fiction: he altered the historical context. But he made this broken timeline into parallel segments and compared them, as in a scientific experiment.


I published this essay on my evolution blog earlier this fall.

Saturday, August 20, 2016

Some Political Insights from Literature: Carson McCullers

I recently read The Heart is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers. It contained some passages that help us understand the political frustration that progressives feel today. I merely quote these passages for your appreciation.

One of the passages was spoken by Jake Blount the communist. His feelings reflect the frustration of millions of low-wage workers today who dare not speak out against their oppression:

‘And look what has happened to our freedom. The men who fought the American Revolution were no more like these D. A. R. dames than I’m a pot-bellied, perfumed Pekingese dog. They meant what they said about freedom. They fought a real revolution. They fought so that this could be a country where every man could be free and equal. Huh! And that meant every man was equal in the sight of Nature—with an equal chance. That didn’t mean that twenty per cent of the people were free to rob the other eighty per cent of the means to live. This didn’t mean for one rich man to sweat the piss out of ten thousand poor men so that he can get richer. This didn’t mean the tyrants were free to get this country in such a fix that millions of people are ready to do anything—cheat, lie, or whack off their right arm—just to work for three squares and a flop. They have made the word freedom a blasphemy. You hear me? They have made the word freedom stink like a skunk to all who know.’

Another passage was spoken by the black doctor Benedict Copeland, who was giving a sermon to poor blacks gathered at his house for a funeral:


‘Land, clay, timber—those things are called natural resources. Man does not make these natural resources—man only develops them and uses them for work. Therefore should any one person or group of persons own these things? Can a man own ground and space and sunlight and rain for crops? How can a man say “this is mine” about those things and refuse to let others share them? Therefore Marx says that these natural resources should belong to everyone, not divided into little pieces but used by all the people according to their ability to work…Say a man died and left his mule to his four sons. The sons would not wish to cut up the mule into four parts and each take his share. They would own and work the mule together. This is the way Marx says all of the natural resources should be owned—not by one group of rich people but by all the workers in the world as a whole.


‘We in this room have no private properties…All that we own is our bodies. And we sell our bodies every day we live. We sell them when we go out in the morning to our jobs and when we labor all the day. We are forced to sell at any price, at any time, for any purpose. We are forced to sell our bodies so that we can eat and live. And the price which is given us for this is only enough so that we will have the strength to labor longer for the profits of others. Today we are not put up on the platforms and sold at the courthouse square, but we are forced to sell our strength, our time, our souls during almost every hour that we live. We have been freed from one kind of slavery only to be delivered into another. Is this freedom? Are we yet free men?...

‘And we are not alone in this slavery. There are millions of others throughout the world, of all colors and races and creeds. This we must remember. There are many of our people who hate the poor of the white race, and they hate us. The people in this town living by the river who work in the mills. People who are almost as much in need as we are ourselves. This hatred is a great evil, and no good can ever come from it. We must remember the words of Karl Marx and see the truth according to his teachings. The injustice of need must bring us all together and not separate us. We must remember that we all make the things on this earth of value because of our labor.’

Sunday, July 31, 2016

Horrors of War, Pleasures of Peace

I have begun posting a series of essays from my recent trip to France on my science blog. I will also post here the entries that have some religious significance.


On July 13, my wife and I visted the Musée Historique de Strasbourg. On July 15, we were back in Old Strasbourg at the Place Kléber (Kleber Plaza) and the Cathedral. What I saw at those times was immensely moving and significant and may have been my most memorable experience in France.



The museum documented a thousand years of history in which Strasbourg, on the Rhine River, was nearly always consumed in war between places that are now part of France and now part of Germany. Throughout this time, Strasbourg thought of itself as Alsacian rather than strictly French or strictly German. And why not? Whichever side it took, it would be conquered by the other side within a century or two anyway. And while it was fun to dress up in simulated medieval armor (see photo), there is no avoiding the fact that this constant state of warfare was gruesome and entailed unmeasurable amounts of suffering.


Most striking of all were the centuries of religious intolerance and slaughter. Throughout most of the history of Strasbourg, as in all other European cities, the Jews were forced to live in ghettos; near the museum you can still walk on the Rue des Juifs, which is very narrow just as it was in ghetto days, only it is now clean and free.



Then there was the Reformation, when Alsace was divided up into little enclaves: Territoires passés a la Réforme (territories becoming Protestant at the Reformation), Territories restés catholiques (territories remaining Catholic), Zones où la Réforme a été combattue (combat zones), and (the smallest of all) Territoires où les deux confessions ont été tolerées (zones where both “confessions” were tolerated) (see photo). 



Inevitably, toward the end of the tour of the museum, we saw the photos and artifacts of Nazi occupation in World War II. The French did not simply surrender; they had a heavily fortified Maginot Line right in Alsace, ready to defend France from a German invasion across the Rhine. But the Germans invaded Belgium and took over France from the north, making the Maginot Line useless. In the museum we saw a photo of Hitler standing at the base of Strasbourg Cathedral, and of big Nazi military displays in the Place Kléber, which they renamed Karl Roos Platz. There was even a display about brutal Nazi experimentation on living humans. When liberation came, under General Leclerc, the Nazi influence was swept away with great enthusiasm (see the photos).








Here is the part that meant the most to me. A couple of days later, on July 15, when my wife and I happened by the Cathedral—there very Cathedral where Jews were oppressed for centuries, and where Hitler walked—we saw a klezmer band making some of the most joyous Jewish music you ever heard. Everybody loved this Jewish music and its talented performers. Take that, Hitler! And take that, you priests who oppressed the Jews for millennia! Right at that moment, while the lead musician (who played my old instrument the euphonium) was when I felt, more than ever before in my life, the joy of international peace, the brotherhood and sisterhood of the human species.



Friday, July 17, 2015

The Quiverfull Delusion

Many American Christians are adherents of the Quiverfullmovement, which is one of the most oppressive and evil ideas to have ever used Christianity as a means of spreading. Its adherents consider themselves Christians, while in reality they are showing God just how much they despise his creation and the other people with whom they, whether they like it or not, share it.

The Quiverfull Delusion is not a Christian idea. It is based on Old Testament concepts that might actually have made sense thousands of years ago but which are not, in fact, incorporated into New Testament law. There are two main ideas on which the delusion is based. First, Genesis 1 has God telling humans to “be fruitful and multiply and fill the Earth.” Second, there is a psalm that says that having lots of sons makes a man happy “when his quiver is full of them,” as if they were arrows.

Let us suppose, for the moment, that the Genesis and Psalm references are valid for modern life. Maybe God really did want humans to be fruitful and multiply and fill the Earth. Well, there are over seven billion people in the world, so we have already filled the Earth. Time to do something else already. The way I demonstrate this idea to my students is to fill a glass with water. Once all of the students agree that the glass is full, I proceed to pour more water into the glass so that the water spills all over the floor. It makes a mess. God did not command humans to overfill the Earth and to create a far worse mess than the one that I created. And what about the Psalm reference to a quiver full of sons? A quiver is something light that you can carry on your back. The psalmist did not say, happy is the man who tries to pull along a quiver that is as big as an elephant.

The Quiverfull Delusion uses religion as an excuse to afflict the Earth (which religious people supposedly believe is God’s creation) with resource depletion and pollution. High population densities also make conflict nearly inevitable.

The Quiverfull Delusion also uses religion as an excuse to afflict women. The man is happy if his quiver is full and that itching sensation in his dick gets relieved. The woman? Shut yo mouth and spread yo legs. I know that is not a Bible verse, but it is, in fact, the fundamental scripture upon which the Quiverfull Delusion is based. The ultimate power of the delusion is that men have convinced many women that they want this. It is psychological tyranny, carried out by men who pretend to be shocked at sexual immorality but whose prime directive in life is unlimited sperm production.


As you might expect, the best insight into this question, as into most questions, comes from Marx. Groucho Marx, that is. When he interviewed a woman for his TV show You Bet Your Life, she said she had seven kids. “I love my husband,” she said. Groucho said, “I love my cigar but I take it out of my mouth once in a while.”

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Stages of Conquest

The Native American nations have suffered nearly complete conquest by the descendants of white Europeans, both from the outside and from the inside. From the outside, by physical conquest, and from the inside, by conversion to religious views that tend to justify white superiority. Not much is left except the glowing coals of cultural identity and even these can be, as in the case of my own Cherokee tribe, which is more white than red, very dim.

There have been at least three stages of this conquest. Starting over 500 years ago, Europeans came to North and South America and began killing and enslaving natives, taking their land, and introducing diseases that decimated their populations. This mostly occurred on the east coast. Many Native American tribes moved westward to get away from this conquest. This resulted in a westward push, in which eastern tribes pushed other tribes toward the west, compressing them and forcing them into conflict. Many of the intertribal conflicts were therefore caused indirectly by Europeans.

In some cases, smaller tribes took refuge with larger ones, merging with them even if they kept their own cultural identity. Therefore by the 1800s the larger tribes contained smaller ones. For example, the Coushattas, Yuchis, and Natchis were compressed into the Muskogee Creek tribe, and some of the Ottawas, Quapaws, and Delawares into the Cherokee tribe. This was the first stage of conquest: Europeans compressed smaller tribes into the larger ones.

The second stage was when the United States conquered the larger tribes. For the Cherokees and Muskogees, this was the Trail of Tears during the 1830s. When the Cherokees and Muskogees (as well as three other tribes) were forced into what is now Oklahoma, the remnants of the smaller tribes went with them. When what became Indian Territory was divided among the “Five Civilized Tribes,” individuals of the smaller tribes had allotments within the land of the larger tribes. To this day, you can find Quapaws living among Cherokees in northeastern Oklahoma, and Yuchis with the Creeks. For years, driving between Durant and Tulsa, Oklahoma, I passed through Wetumka, a little town which happens to be the headquarters of the Alabama Quassarte Tribal Town. I did not know it existed until they got a storefront building and painted a sign on it. I searched online to find out who they were. Quassarte is a variant form of Coushatta.

We often think of this second stage of conquest as the first: independent tribes got conquered by Europeans and later Americans. But in many cases, smaller tribes were conquered by Americans only after Americans had forced them to take refuge with larger tribes.

The third stage occurred when Americans swindled from the Natives the land allotments that the government had given them. In Oklahoma, this occurred immediately before and after statehood in 1907. For example, the conquered Creek people were given land allotments, with the Yuchi and Coushatta among them, but white swindlers, in collusion with white judges, quickly took these allotments away from them. In many cases they did so by forged deeds that claimed the Natives had sold the land to them; or, the white land speculators lied about the amount of money they were paying for the land by conveniently misplacing a decimal point so that the Native seller ended up getting only one-tenth as much money as he or she was promised. In many cases, Native children (and adults) were placed under “guardianship” and the “guardians” kept most of the money for themselves. In a few cases, the swindlers got the Natives to leave the land to them as heirs, and then they killed the Natives. In such ways, the large tribes were conquered a second time, and the small tribes a third time.

This is the reason that many Natives in Oklahoma live in desperate poverty even though their land allotments a hundred years ago often contained rich reserves of oil. And this poverty is evident if you drive through Native communities in the midst of rich oil land. Consider Wetumka, the city where the Alabama Quassarte Tribal Town is located. For the first few years I drove through, nearly every building I saw was dilapidated. Then new buildings began to arise, very fancy and rich amidst the rubble of the old buildings. The first was, of course, a bank. Next came two buildings associated with providing medical care to the Natives. You see, many of the Native Americans rely on health care at government expense because they are poor; and they are poor because white Americans stole their land.


The Americans who stole the land reaped immense private profits, but the conquered Natives must now be assisted at public expense. Private corporations got the profits, while the taxpayers ended up with the costs. This happens a lot. For example, tobacco corporations got rich while taxpayers paid medical expenses of people who got cancer and emphysema. It was not until the tobacco lawsuit that was settled in 1999 that the tobacco corporations ever paid any money for the damage that their products did, and then only a small portion of it. A similar thing will soon happen with global warming: the Koch Brothers get rich from oil and carbon pollution, but when it comes time to build sea walls to keep the rising ocean waters out of Miami, it will be at public expense. But when you see the poverty of Native American communities, you see the human face of private profits at public expense, and the lingering evidence of the white conquest of Native American nations.

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Black Gold

For the last century, the most important source of energy for the human economy has been oil. We hear all the time, not the least from my blogs, about the environmental costs, including global climate change, of our oil dependence. And while it may seem like a distant memory even to those of us who lived through it, dependence on foreign oil has caused immense economic and geopolitical instability. It has taken decades for America to get to the point at which we import less oil than we produce, but we still use a lot of foreign oil. And we spew a lot of carbon into the air.

What I wish to address now is the immense toll of injustice that comes from our dependence on oil. Oil is a highly concentrated source of energy, both in terms of the number of calories of energy per volume and in the concentration of oil resources in specific geographical areas. In contrast, sunlight shines more or less evenly on the Earth’s surface. Although some places in the world are cloudier than others, and places far to the north or south get significantly less sunlight, solar energy is broadly distributed. The same is almost as true of wind energy. Low-level geothermal energy (which can be used to stabilize indoor temperatures) is also widespread, although only a few places have really hot rocks near the surface that can allow steam turbines to produce electricity. The fact that oil is concentrated in a few places means that whoever controls those places (whether governments or corporations) has an immense amount of geopolitical power.

And it is not necessarily the people who live in those places who have the power.

Native Americans from all over what is now the United States were forced into what is now Oklahoma, mostly in the nineteenth century, so that white people could have their land. The white-dominated government of the U.S. supposedly had a constitution, but whites broke every treaty with Native Americans, in complete disregard of the constitution as well as the most basic concepts of dignity and humanity. Then, much to the consternation of the government, oil was discovered on Indian land. While in some cases (as with the Osage tribe) this meant wealth for the Native Americans, what it usually meant was that whites decided to take Native land by any means necessary or imaginable, to treat Natives like vermin, as nothing more than impediments to oil production. By and large, having oil land has been a curse to Native Americans. I am speaking from the viewpoint of Oklahoma, where I was born and where I live, and the experiences of my Cherokee ancestors.

If you want to know about the many devious ways in which whites illegally took Native American land and oil rights, the most definitive source remains Angie Debo’s And Still the Waters Run: The Betrayal of the Five Civilized Tribes. It is about how the land promised and then allotted to Cherokees, Chickasaws, Choctaws, Muskogees, and Seminoles was stolen from them (us) during the twentieth century. Lies and forged documents were routinely used to defraud tribal members. The courts appointed “guardians” to take care of the supposedly simple-minded Indians; these guardians would then sell or rent the allotted land and keep all, or most, of the money. In one case, a guardian had 51 Indians under his control. Three of them were children who held title to very productive oil land, but the guardian did not tell them about it. They were living in a hollow tree and begging for food when a conscientious state government agent found them. In this one case, the “guardian” had his privileges taken away; but this rarely happened. And this “guardian” never went to jail. Jail was for drunk Indians, not for the whites who defrauded them. And even today, prison is mostly for poor drug offenders, not for financial crimes committed by the rich, with an occasional exception like Bernard Madoff.

But it wasn’t just fraud that whites committed to get oil land from Indians (and from freed slaves within the Indian nations). It was also murder. The whites would trick the Indians (some of them children) to making them the heirs, and then they would kill them. In Glenn Pool (now called Glenpool, right down the highway from my house in Tulsa) whites dynamited two black Muskogee boys while they slept to get their land. Glenn Pool was the massive oil deposit that made Tulsa famous. In Choctaw County, the next county over from the place where I work, whites killed Choctaws with carbolic acid or ground glass (put in their food to make them bleed to death from the inside) in order to get their land.

When I read this, on page 200 of Debo’s book, I could not do or think about anything else all evening, just devastated by learning about this. For those of you who think that the last time that whites massacred Indians was at Wounded Knee in 1890, think again! Everyone has heard about the four little black girls who got burned in the church fire set by white arsonists in the 1960s, but has anyone ever heard about those two little black boys in Glenn Pool? At least my ancestors were only defrauded, not murdered.

My point is that nobody has ever defrauded or murdered anyone else in order to get a choice spot for putting up a wind generator or a solar collector. There will never be a Koch Brothers of solar energy.

Is it any wonder that so many Native Americans (and Native American freedmen) are so demoralized? Especially the ones who still live in their own ethnic communities. The white governments of the United States and of Oklahoma have driven them into the ground. Toxic waste sites are often near communities of color; and in Oklahoma, that means Native American communities, such as the Cherokee-Quapaw town of Picher, which drips with toxic metal contamination.

I would expect to see Native American rage over these things, but the steamrolling of Native pride by white culture has been so complete that Natives are in some cases embarrassed to not be white. What should Native Americans do? There is no clear answer. In his 1970 novel The Ordeal of Running Standing, Thomas Fall wrote about a fullblood Oklahoma Indian who tried to be white and use the powers of the white economy against rich whites, failed, and then did a useless but heroic act of defiance against the overwhelming white powers. (If you want to know what it was, you have to read my review in the previous blog entry.) But nothing like this ever happened or ever will. The Indian nations are conquered now and forever. And oil was part of the reason.

As I said, I speak from Oklahoma experience. But anyone who listens to the news knows that rich people (some of them black) get even richer from the lucrative oil reserves in Nigeria, while the poor black Nigerians live in desperate poverty. And today the struggle continues in Ecuador, where oil companies take some land from the native tribes of the Amazon, and pour their wastes on the rest of it. El Oriente of Ecuador (east of the Andes) is the new Oklahoma.


Moving away from energy-dense fuel sources is essential for the ecological and economic future of the world, and also so that, at long last, justice can be done in the world. Oil is just too much of a temptation; it makes evil people destroy their fellow humans.

Thursday, February 20, 2014

The Ordeal of the Native Americans

I recently re-read Thomas Fall’s 1971 novel The Ordeal of Running Standing. As far as I can tell, it is the only novel Thomas Fall ever wrote, and it is unavailable in its original form. University of Oklahoma Press reissued it, with a new foreword, in 1993, and this edition is still available for purchase. I consider it to be one of the best novels I have read. As a Native American, I have a personal interest in this type of literature.

It begins on Indian reservation lands in western Oklahoma in the late nineteenth century, where numerous tribes with mutually incomprehensible languages have been thrown together. They have been demoralized by conquest, yearn for the glory days before the white man, and end up accomplishing just about nothing. The only way out seemed to be the Jesus Road: young Indians (such as the incipient lovers Running Standing, a Kiowa renamed Joe Standing, and Crosses-the-River, a Cheyenne renamed Sara Cross) go off to boarding school to become white.

And doesn’t Joe Standing become white! The oil tycoons are interested in hiring him. He does not realize it, but what they want him to do is to go back to Oklahoma and convince his tribe (and his wife Sara’s tribe) to sign the oil rights to them. Now why would Joe Standing want to do this? Because he thought he had figured out a way in which he could trick the whites at their own game, and end up controlling the oil companies in order to benefit, not exploit, the Oklahoma tribes. Of course, they have tricked him, something he learns only after he has used his good graces to steal his people’s land.

He wanted to be white in order to be Indian, and it didn’t work. This was his ordeal. After becoming a white Indian, he tried to reclaim his heritage, and discovered that he didn’t know the first thing about living in the woods, much less about meditating in them.

It is a beautifully-written book, with just enough romance to make us really care about the characters. The Indians aren’t all good nor are the whites all bad.

The climax begins when Joe accidentally kills one of the oil company representatives. A marshal convinces Joe to turn himself in for manslaughter, and when he does, the marshal decides instead to trap, torture, and kill him. This is when Joe realizes that almost all white people—except a neighborly white farmer’s family, and a white doctor—are vicious liars who have no concept of honor. This is when Joe has the opportunity to attack the president of the oil company, who happens to be in town, in a very dramatic and very Indian manner, just before his own death dance.

About the only way that Native peoples can have any sense of release in response to the overwhelming injustice done to them (to us) is to read things like this novel and fantasize about revenge. And part of the total conquest of Native peoples has been the internal conquest by what Fall calls the Jesus Road. By and large, Christianity over the years (in Oklahoma) has taught that God intended the white men to bring civilization to the childlike Indians. Some grade school teachers still take this approach. One of them, who became an Oklahoma state representative, was proud of teaching history the old-fashioned way, without this liberal hogwash of Native rights. She undoubtedly would not approve of the murder of Indians. But that is what happened during the Manifest Destiny of white conquest. This teacher’s creationism was inseparable from her belief in benign white supremacy.


I will close with some quotes. Joe was explaining the White Way to Sara. “The white way of life was a simple but well-made pattern…wherein rich and powerful people controlled the government by putting their own people into the law-making bodies. ‘And they use the Jesus Road as a smoke screen to hide it all from the common people. Haven’t you ever wondered why rich white men give so much money to the churches? We don’t need an Indian state, Sara. We need an Indian business. Business powerful enough to control politics. That’s what the white way of life is all about. That’s civilization…There’s a way. If we take a leaf from the white man’s book. His real book, and not the one with gold edges that he reads in church.’”